Comparing the 2 most common medicare plans

Still confused about Medicare Plans?

We get it.

Researching Medicare plans can be like taking a trip down the rabbit hole.

This guide clarifies your options, fast.

expression - If you chase two rabbits, you will not catch eithe

(Get this page as a condensed downloadable cheatsheet, plus checklist.  Click here to get this free printable guide!)

But first: Do you really need to supplement Medicare Parts A & B?

Supplemental coverage is a good idea, because without it, you expose yourself to great financial risk if hospitalized for more than 60 days.  Other risks include skilled nursing beyond 20 days, chemotherapy, outpatient radiology, outpatient surgeries, etc.

Bottom Line: There is no out of pocket maximum spending limit for Original Medicare.

The good news is, both Medicare Supplements (Medigap) and Medicare Advantage Plans provide a built in cap (out of pocket maximum) for expenses covered by Medicare.

In this guide, we’re comparing the 2 most common medicare plans:

Medicare Supplement (Medigap) & Medicare Advantage.

Medicare Supplements & Medicare Advantage are NOT the same thing?-2

Most seniors choose ONE of the following options:

1.) Keep Original Medicare (Parts A & B), add a Medigap Policy, + stand-alone drug plan.


2.) Enroll in a Medicare Advantage Plan (another way to receive your Medicare benefits).

(Some seniors opt to keep Original Medicare and not supplement it at all.  We don’t recommend it and won’t be discussing that option here.)

Medigap Vs. Medicare Advantage

Possibly one of the most misunderstood facts about Medicare plans is that Medicare Supplements and Medicare Advantage are not the same thing.

It can make anyone crazy.


The terms Medicare Supplement and Medigap are used interchangeably, which adds to the confusion.

A Medicare Supplement, or Medigap Plan is gap insurance that covers your out of pocket expenses on Medicare.  Medicare pays your doctor its portion of the claim, then the Medicare Supplement pays its portion.

What you should know about Medigap:

  • Monthly premium
  • No network restrictions
  • Standardized (every carrier offers the exact same benefits)
  • Drug plan must be purchased separately

In contrast to Medigap, Medicare Advantage (aka Medicare Part C) is an alternate way to receive your Medicare benefits.

Hospital, doctor, and sometimes Part D (drugs) are bundled together and administered through private insurance at Medicare’s expense.

What you should know about Medicare Advantage:

  • Typically zero, or very low premium
  • Usually an HMO (sometimes PPO) = possible network restrictions & referrals
  • Often includes Medicare Part D (prescription drugs)
  • Benefits and providers can change annually
  • Sometimes includes benefits medicare doesn’t cover, such as dental

Next, we’ve created two lists. (Use this next section like a checklist).

Prioritize Plan qualities!

Each list contains descriptive statements about that particular plan type.

Find out what qualities in a plan matter most to you by reading through each list.

Make a mental checklist of the qualities that resonate most with you.  The plan list with the most “check-marks” is likely the best fit for you. This gives you a starting point for further research or when you’re ready to shop for plans.

 List #1 Medicare Supplement (Medigap)

  • It’s worth it to pay more for the freedom to go to the doctors and specialists of my choice. I dislike the restriction of networks.
  • It’s important that I can go directly to a specialist without a referral.
  • I like knowing I can go to any doctor or hospital in the country that accepts Medicare.
  • I’d rather pay a higher premium each month, knowing I will have little, to no out­of­ pocket expenses when I do get sick.
  • I don’t mind having a separate prescription plan, with additional premium.

List #2 Medicare Advantage

  • As long as my doctor is in­ network, I wouldn’t mind an HMO.
  • I like the security of managed care, even though referrals are required. I feel I’m taken care of.
  • As long as my favorite hospital is in my plan network, I’m happy.
  • A zero, or low monthly premium is very important to me. I don’t mind doctor or hospital copays, and can accept some financial risk.
  • I like having all my benefits under one plan, including prescriptions.

How many qualities in each list really stand out to you?  One list or plan-type should be the clear winner.

The key to your Medicare Plan decision

Still Not Sure?

Important Points to Ponder:

Think in terms of securing your future:  Your acceptance into a Medigap policy is NOT guaranteed after the first 6 month on Medicare Part B.  (Beyond that you will have to answer medical questions). The only way to guarantee you’ll have a Medigap plan in the future is to enroll when first eligible.

Secure your future

Is plan stability important to you? Medicare Advantage Plans are year­-to-­year contracts. Benefits and doctor networks may change every year (not very stable).

To some, freedom is priceless: Two main benefits of Medigap policies are 1.) freedom (no networks), and 2.) predictable monthly cost.

Weigh your risk: Two risks involved with Medicare Advantage Plans are 1.) unknown cost of chemotherapy &  2.) skilled nursing costs beyond 20 days. (See plan finder to view detailed plan benefits in your zip code).

What next? You may contact us, find a licensed agent, or directly shop individual carriers online to find the pricing for the plan type you choose.  Compile a list of questions and qualities you prefer in a plan before speaking with a professional.

Let us help you choose a Medicare Plan!

Resources: ­ is great for searching Medicare Advantage plans and stand alone drug plans, & includes plan premiums.

Many state Dept of Insurance websites will show pricing for Medicare Supplements (Medigap) plans.

How to choose a Medicare Plan

Have any remaining questions?  Did we leave anything out?

We’d love to hear your comments, questions, or concerns, in the comments section below.